When I Knew is currently streaming on HBO Max

When I Knew (2009)35 minDocumentaryRating 57/100

Candid, funny and heartbreaking, this film focuses on a cross-section of men and women who invoke the exact moment -- whether as toddlers, grade-schoolers, teens or young adults -- when they knew, once and for all, that they were gay. Inspired by writer Robert Trachtenberg, filmmakers Fenton Bailey and Randy Barbato set out across the country to interview these men and woman.

Cast: Jeffrey Patrick Olson, Ashley Arnold, Melissa Marie Gibson, James Evans, Charlene Geisler

Director: Fenton Bailey, Randy Barbato